Home  Contact Us
  Follow Us On:
 
Search:
Advertising Advertising Free Newsletter Free E-Newsletter
NEWS

Man fined 140,000 yuan for pruning his own camphor tree
Published on: 2021-08-17
Share to
User Rating: / 0
PoorBest 

A Shanghai resident has been fined 140,000 yuan for pruning a camphor tree that he planted.
 

The resident, identified by his surname Li, had initially planted the tree in his courtyard in 2002 after paying 10,000 yuan for it.
 

He, however, decided to relocate it a few years later as the tree had grown too tall, blocking out sunlight.
 

Li started pruning the tree, which had grown to about two metres tall, in January after it blocked sunshine to his home.
 

Workers removed all the tree’s branches, leaving the tree trunk.
 

Shanghai’s local urban management department spokesman Zhu Xiaoxi was quoted as saying that individuals had no right to transplant and cut trees on public green spaces without the approval of the related departments.
 

According to Zhu, if the tree was planted in residents’ own courtyard and the diameter of the tree was less than 25 centimeters, the tree can be dealt with by residents themselves.
 

The matter triggered a wide discussion among Chinese internet users with many suggesting an administrative warning would be sufficient.
 

Some suggested Li appeal against the fine while others said local authorities should educate the people about their regulations before punishing offenders.
 

“修剪”门前一棵自买的香樟树被罚14万

松江区明华路366弄绿洲比华利花园是一个别墅小区,住在这里的李先生最近碰上了一件头疼事。
 

今年1月20日,他请人来修剪一棵香樟树,这棵树是他在2002年花1.1万元买来的,此前他将树种在院子内,随着香樟树越长越高,遮挡了家中的阳光,几年后,李先生又将香樟树移到了院外,又过了数年,香樟树继续生长,再次挡住了院内花草的阳光,李先生这才决定将香樟树修剪一番。
 

于是他请来工人,将树的分枝全部砍除,剩余2米多高的主干,在李先生看来,这棵树本就是他买的,如今雇人来修剪也是理所应当的。
 

然而,李先生却因此被居民举报至城管部门,经调查,城管工作人员向李先生开具了一张行政处罚书,罚款人民币14.42万元。
 

为什么会这样?城管部门工作人员朱晓曦给出了这样的解释:“个人在未得到区绿化部门审批前,是没有权利对公共绿地上的树木进行移植和砍伐的。”
 

朱晓曦说,即便李先生说这棵树是他买的,但因为数年前种在院外,已属于公共绿化,如果需要修剪树木,只能通过养护部门修剪,同时在修剪过程中也必须按照标准执行。
 

朱晓曦说,只有在一种情况下,居民才能自行处置树木,那就是树木在自己家院落内,且树木胸径小于25厘米,否则如果树木胸径过大,即使修剪种在家里的树木也会受到相应处罚。
 

“城管说我砍伐树木,我承认修剪有些过度,但是这树就是我买的,我不舍得砍死的。”李先生想不明白,自己并未把树“砍死”,而今香樟树也冒出了绿芽,怎么就被认定为砍伐树木了?
 

就在2019年,李先生所在的小区隔壁,四季御庭小区也出现过类似情况,小区物业将150余棵树木修剪成树干,外观看与李先生修剪的程度相似,最终物业被城管以“修剪过度”为由,罚款1.5万元。
 

“如果大家都是这么罚,那我也认,但是修剪的程度都一样,他们还剪了这么多树,为什么罚款差这么多?”李先生无奈地问。
 

根据上海市绿化和市容管理局制定的《居住区常见树木修剪指南》(以下简称“指南”)显示,李先生“修剪”的是一棵香樟树,其中,香樟树“过度修剪”的标准是保留少许枝干,如果再往下剪,就属于“砍伐”,而李先生已经把香樟树砍成了树桩,因此是砍伐而不是过度修剪。
 

“四季御庭小区物业修剪的是意杨,杨树的一种,这种树‘过度修剪’的标准就是没有树枝,因此物业不属于砍伐。”朱晓曦说,首先,物业部门属于养护部门,有修剪树木的权利,其次,由于香樟树和意杨的修剪标准不同,因此裁定标准就发生了变化。

Comments (0)Add Comment

Write comment

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
    Subscription    |     Advertising    |     Contact Us    |
Address: Magnetic Plaza, Building A4, 6th Floor, Binshui Xi Dao.
Nankai District. 300381 TIANJIN. PR CHINA
Tel: +86 22 23917700
E-mail: webmaster@businesstianjin.com
Copyright 2024 BusinessTianjin.com. All rights reserved.